Labor is the most complex expense on a restaurant P&L. It is also, for most operators, the largest — and the one with the most moving parts. Food cost is a single number. Labor is a system of overlapping costs that are easy to underestimate when you’re budgeting and easy to misread when you’re reviewing a P&L.
Most operators think of labor as wages. Wages are the starting point, but they are not the finish line. The true cost of labor in a restaurant includes several additional line items that can add 20 to 30 percent on top of gross wages — costs that show up in different places on the P&L and are often tracked inconsistently or not at all.
Understanding every layer of what you are actually paying for labor is the first step toward managing it.
Hourly Wages
This is the most visible piece — the wages paid to hourly employees for time worked. It includes your line cooks, servers, bartenders, hosts, bussers, dishwashers, and any other hourly positions. It is calculated directly from your scheduling software or time clock and is typically your largest single labor line.
Hourly wages fluctuate with your sales volume, your scheduling decisions, and your management of overtime. They are the most controllable piece of labor — you cannot eliminate them, but you can shape them week to week through disciplined scheduling and real-time floor management.
Salaried Management
Salaried labor is fixed — it does not move with sales volume, which makes it behave differently than hourly labor on your P&L. In a strong week, salaried labor looks cheap as a percentage of sales. In a slow week, it looks expensive. Over time, it needs to be sized to what your average volume can support, not your best weeks.
Many operators track salaried and hourly labor separately in their reporting. This is worth doing — it separates the costs you can adjust quickly from the ones that require a structural decision to change.
Payroll Taxes
Every dollar of wages you pay triggers a matching payroll tax obligation. The employer’s share of FICA — Social Security and Medicare — is 7.65 percent of gross wages. This is non-negotiable, applies to every employee, and is often overlooked when operators calculate their labor percentage.
On top of FICA, you pay FUTA (federal unemployment tax) and SUTA (state unemployment tax). SUTA rates vary by state and by your claims history — operators with high turnover and frequent unemployment claims pay higher rates. It is not unusual for total payroll taxes to add 10 to 12 percent on top of gross wages when all components are included.
Workers’ Compensation Insurance
Workers’ comp is a mandatory insurance program that covers employees injured on the job. Restaurant workers — particularly kitchen staff — are classified as high-risk, which translates into higher premium rates. Workers’ comp is typically calculated as a rate per $100 of payroll, and that rate varies by job classification.
A kitchen worker might carry a workers’ comp rate of $7 to $12 per $100 of wages. A server or host, considered lower risk, might be $3 to $5 per $100. If you are running $50,000 per week in gross wages with a blended rate of $6 per $100, you are paying $3,000 per week — or roughly $156,000 per year — in workers’ comp premiums alone. Many operators do not track this as part of their labor cost percentage and are consistently surprised by the annual premium invoice.
Employee Benefits
Benefits vary widely by operator and concept size. At minimum, most full-service restaurants offer some combination of meal benefits and limited paid time off. Larger operators or those competing for talent in tight labor markets add health insurance, dental, vision, and retirement contributions.
Health insurance for restaurant workers is expensive. A modest employer contribution to a group health plan can add $200 to $400 per month per covered employee. If you offer health insurance to 20 employees and contribute $250 per month per person, that is $60,000 per year — a line item that belongs in labor cost and often does not make it there in smaller operators’ P&Ls.
Overtime
Overtime — federal law requires time-and-a-half for any hours worked over 40 in a workweek — is one of the most controllable and most mismanaged labor costs in restaurants. Overtime typically happens for two reasons: poor scheduling and floor management decisions that let hours run, or an unexpected surge in volume that required additional coverage.
Systematic overtime — week after week, on the same employees — is a scheduling problem. It means you are understaffed structurally and relying on overtime to fill the gap rather than adding a position. The math rarely works in your favor: paying $22.50 per hour in overtime for a $15-per-hour employee is meaningfully more expensive than adding a part-time position and scheduling more carefully.
What Your True Labor Cost Percentage Should Include
When operators report labor cost as a percentage of sales, they should be including all of the above: hourly wages, salaried labor, payroll taxes, workers’ comp, and benefits. Many operators only include gross wages, which produces an artificially low labor percentage and gives a false read on how the business is actually performing.
If your gross wages are running 28 percent of sales and you add payroll taxes (approximately 10 percent of wages, or 2.8 points), workers’ comp (approximately 6 percent of wages, or 1.7 points), and benefits (varies), your true all-in labor cost may be 33 to 35 percent — a meaningful difference from what the simplified number suggests.
Understanding the full picture is not an academic exercise. It is the foundation of accurate budgeting, honest P&L review, and the kind of cost management that actually moves the needle.
The author is a former CFO for a multi-unit restaurant brand. RestaurantBottomLine.com is dedicated to helping independent operators protect their financial model.
PROTECTING THE BOTTOM LINE 